2012

Natalie Pietrzak

---

2011

Alida D’Angona

---

2010

Lacey Wilson

---

2009

Alison Michele Cronin

---

2008

Jackie Bruno

Top 10 at Miss USA

---

2007

Despina Delios

---

2006

Tiffany Kelly

---

2005

Cristina Nardozi

---

2004

Maria Lekkakos

---

2003

Susie Castillo

Miss USA

---

2002

Latoyia Cimone Foster

---

2001

Dana Tenille Powell

---

2000

Rosalie M. Allain

---

1999

Jennifer Krafve

---

1998

Shawnae Jebbia

Miss USA

---

1997

Jennifer K. Chapman

---

1996

Jacqueline Doucette

---

1995

Kristen Mastroianni

Semi-Finalist

---

1994

Michelle Atamian

---

1993

Stacey Blaine

Miss Congeniality

---

1992

Christine Netishen

---

1991

Laura Wheeler

---

1990

Laureen Murphy

---

1989

Kimberley Wallace

---

1988

Anita Marie Lovely

---

1987

Rosanna Iversen

---

1986

Sheila Benson

---

1985

Mercedes Waggoner

Semi-Finalist

---

1984

Deborah Neary

---

1983

Robin Jeanne Silva

---

1982

Janet Marie Flaherty

Semi-Finalist

---

1981

JoAnne Savery

---

1980

Diane Campbell

---

1979

Monica Patricia Magnus

Semi-Finalist

---

1978

Diane Elizabeth Pollard

1st Runner-Up

---

1977

Carol Marcil

---

1976

Holly Ann Hoyle

---

1975

Rilla Posson

---

1974

Ethellean Hicks

---

1973

Judith Ann “Judy” Gregory

---

1972

Dale Carder

---

1971

April Dow

---

1970

Cheryl Stankiewicz

---

1969

Martha Cawley

---

1968

Sonja Prince

---

1967

Pamela Procter

---

1966

Nancy Joan Brackett

Semi-Finalist

---

1965

Mary Lou Volpe

---

1964

Barbara Helen Robery

---

1963

Sandra Smith

Semi-Finalist

---

1962

Gale Pope

---

1961

Elaine Cusick

Semi-Finalist

---

1960

Barbara Gale Feldman

Semi-Finalist

---

1959

Beatrice Duprey

---

1958

Sally Ann Freedman

---

1957

Sandra Ramsey

---

1956

Elaine Murphy

---

1955

Jean Dernago

---

1954

Nan Cowan

---

1953

Joan Daly

---

1952

Vel Dorne

---